Talk:Willem Kmetsch/@comment-98.212.12.91-20170708045115/@comment-68.230.35.147-20180130061509

She can't be reincarnated because she did not open the gate, and her soul did not go to the "fairy world". That is why Elq kept on telling Chtholly that if she went back she would "lose lots of important things". Chtholly, by continuing to go back from the fairy world after being summoned by Elq, effectively destroyed all of her memories, and permanently removed "herself" from the pool of reincarnation.

As Elq explained, each fairy is a piece of her soul. So, the piece that Chtholly was made out of still exists, and that is what Riel, the new blue-haired girl, is made out of. But, because Chtholly lost her memories and didn't open the gate the Chtholly we know is gone, and can't ever be reincarnated or "reborn" into a body like Ithea (that we know from the story, not the one who kept the diary) was.